Looking for a cozy, inviting spot to enjoy classic Irish fare and a warm, friendly atmosphere? The Irish Coffee Pub in East Islip might be just what you're after. Known for its hearty meals, welcoming vibe, and authentic Irish touches, this local favorite has been drawing in both residents and visitors for years. Whether you're craving a perfectly cooked steak, fresh seafood, or a taste of Ireland in every bite, the Irish Coffee Pub East Islip has something to offer everyone.

From its prime location at 131 Carleton Ave., this pub has built a reputation for being more than just a restaurant — it's a gathering place, a celebration spot, and a go-to for anyone looking to enjoy a little piece of Ireland right in the heart of Long Island. With a TripAdvisor rating of 4.5 out of 5 and over 177 reviews, it's clear that this isn't just another neighborhood eatery — it's a standout.

Whether you're planning a night out with friends, a family dinner, or a special celebration, the Irish Coffee Pub East Islip promises a memorable experience. Let’s dive into what makes this spot so special and why it's worth checking out.

• G Hannelius Movies And Tv Shows

Table of Contents

• Location & Directions
• Exploring the Menu
• Atmosphere & Vibe
• Customer Reviews & Reputation
• Special Events & Occasions
• Frequently Asked Questions

Location & Directions: Where to Find Irish Coffee Pub East Islip

Situated at 131 Carleton Ave, East Islip, NY 11730, the Irish Coffee Pub is easy to find and even easier to enjoy. Whether you're coming from the North, South, or neighboring towns, getting here is a breeze. You can use any major map service like Google Maps or Apple Maps to get turn-by-turn directions based on your starting point.

There's parking nearby, and the pub is nestled in a part of East Islip that’s both accessible and full of charm. If you're looking for a place that feels like home but with a touch of Irish flair, this is your spot.

Don’t forget to call ahead if you’re unsure or want to confirm hours of operation. The phone number is usually listed online or on their official website if they have one. You can also find more details about the pub's location, including opening times and other contact info, on sites like TripAdvisor or Yelp.

• Prime And Proper Detroit

Exploring the Menu: What’s on Offer at Irish Coffee Pub East Islip

When it comes to food, the Irish Coffee Pub East Islip doesn’t disappoint. Their menu is filled with Irish classics that bring a taste of the Emerald Isle straight to your plate. Think fish and chips that are crispy on the outside and tender on the inside, savory seafood dishes, and entrees that range from traditional to modern takes on old favorites.

Some of the crowd favorites include:

• Fish and Chips – A staple in Irish cuisine, this dish is known for its perfectly seasoned batter and fresh ingredients.
• Seafood Chowder – Creamy, hearty, and full of flavor, it’s a great way to start your meal.
• Aged Steaks – For those who prefer a more American twist, the steaks are cooked just right and full of flavor.
• Irish Stew – A comforting dish made with lamb, potatoes, and herbs, perfect for cooler days.

Drinks are another highlight. Of course, the pub’s namesake — the Irish coffee — is a must-try. It’s made with rich coffee, Irish whiskey, and a smooth layer of whipped cream on top. If you're not into coffee, there are plenty of other drink options, including local and imported beers, wines, and classic cocktails.

For a full list of what’s available, you can check out the menu on TripAdvisor or stop by to see what’s new on the daily specials board.

Atmosphere & Vibe: The Irish Coffee Pub East Islip Experience

Walking into the Irish Coffee Pub East Islip feels like stepping into a warm living room — if your living room had exposed brick, soft lighting, and friendly faces greeting you at the door. The space is elegant but not stuffy, modern but still rooted in tradition. It’s a place where you can dress up for a special occasion or show up in jeans and a tee and still feel perfectly at home.

The staff are known for being incredibly friendly, often remembering regulars by name and making newcomers feel welcome. Music plays softly in the background, sometimes with a live Irish tune or folk melody that adds to the overall charm. It’s not uncommon to hear laughter and conversation bouncing off the walls — a sign of a place that truly brings people together.

There’s also a nice balance between dining and pub-style seating. Whether you're there for a quiet dinner or a drink with friends, there’s a spot for you. And if you're celebrating something special — like a birthday, anniversary, or even St. Patrick’s Day — the pub can accommodate larger groups and events, making it a flexible choice for all kinds of occasions.

Customer Reviews & Reputation: What People Are Saying

With a 4.5 rating on TripAdvisor and over 3,800 reviews on Restaurant Guru, the Irish Coffee Pub East Islip has definitely made a name for itself. Many guests rave about the quality of the food, the cozy atmosphere, and the consistently friendly service.

Common themes in the reviews include:

• “The fish and chips are the best I've had outside of Ireland.”
• “Great spot for a family dinner or a night out with friends.”
• “The staff really makes you feel at home — so welcoming and attentive.”
• “Perfect for St. Patrick’s Day or any day you want a little Irish charm.”

Some reviews also mention that it’s a great place for special events, with many people celebrating birthdays, anniversaries, and even small weddings here. The overall sentiment is overwhelmingly positive, with very few negative comments — and those that exist are often about minor issues that can happen at any restaurant.

If you’re curious, take a look at the photos and videos uploaded by customers on Restaurant Guru or TripAdvisor. You’ll get a real sense of what the place looks like and what kind of crowd it attracts.

Special Events & Occasions: What’s Happening at Irish Coffee Pub East Islip

Whether you're looking for a place to celebrate or just enjoy some live entertainment, the Irish Coffee Pub East Islip hosts a variety of events throughout the year. St. Patrick’s Day is, of course, a big one — think green beer, live music, and plenty of festive energy.

Other events might include:

• Live Music Nights – Featuring local musicians playing everything from traditional Irish tunes to modern covers.
• Themed Dinners – Special menus for holidays or seasonal celebrations.
• Trivia Nights – Fun and competitive, often with prizes.
• Private Events – Whether it’s a birthday, anniversary, or corporate gathering, the pub can be reserved for larger groups.

If you're planning a special occasion, it’s a good idea to call ahead and check about availability and any specific packages they might offer. You can also follow their social media pages for updates on events, happy hour specials, and more.

Frequently Asked Questions About Irish Coffee Pub East Islip

Is the Irish Coffee Pub East Islip family-friendly?

Absolutely. Many guests bring their kids, and the pub offers a menu with options for younger diners too. The atmosphere is laid-back and welcoming for all ages.

Do they offer catering or takeout options?

While the pub is best known for its dine-in experience, some catering options might be available for events. It’s best to call directly to inquire about catering or takeout options for large orders.

Can I book a private event at Irish Coffee Pub East Islip?

Yes, the pub does host private events. Whether it’s a birthday, anniversary, or other celebration, the team is usually happy to accommodate. Contact them directly for more info on capacity, pricing, and available dates.

Final Thoughts

The Irish Coffee Pub East Islip isn’t just a place to grab a bite — it’s an experience. From its warm, welcoming atmosphere to its delicious food and friendly staff, it’s the kind of place that keeps people coming back. Whether you're a local or just visiting, it’s worth stopping by to see what all the rave reviews are about.

Learn more about other popular dining spots in East Islip on our site. If you're looking for a cozy place that feels like home with a touch of Irish charm, the Irish Coffee Pub East Islip should definitely be on your list.